Before I get into the issues I encountered with this book, I would like to point out the things that worked for me as a reader. First off, Pinborough does have a knack for building tension. She does this well during several scenes, such as the widows smashing the survivor groups vehicles and leaving them without cars, all the suspense Nigel brings with his asshole, murderous behavior, the suicide scenes, and when the black spider emerges from John's mouth -- all good stuff laced with intrigue and tension.
Another positive would be that this novel is a quick read and the reader can get absorbed in what's happening (for the most part), and Pinborough does provide that just enough optimism at the end to give readers a little bit of hope. However, I actually expected more at the end than me just guessing what happens to the remaining characters. But even so that wasn't one of my major problems with this book.
Let's talk about our protagonist, Matthew Edge. Sounds like a superhero name, huh? Well let me assure you Matt Edge is not the type to save you from any of your perils. If you're a good-looking woman, he'll probably just bang you, think you're bitchy when you ignore him, and get you pregnant with his spider babies. Oh, but don't worry my fragile female friends, Matt Edge is here to give you comfort in his manly man ways, as long as you act like the fit, feminine,
Matt Edge is on the run from spiders who want to kill/eat him, has just witnessed his girlfriend Chloe who he proclaimed as the love of his life die brutally while birthing his very own spider baby, and yet when he runs into this totally bangable chick named Katie, it's like he can breathe again. *Cue sunshine and rainbows blooming over the webs of demonic spiders*
Oh but wait there's more! Later when the survival group goes looking for a chemist for Dave's unfortunate spider bite, they run into totally bangable chick number 2, Rebecca. "A beautiful deaf girl" as Matt puts it. Even after poor Dave (who was a good character, by the way, so I'll give props to Pinborough for how he was written), has to get his arm amputated and Katie asks Matt if Dave's okay, we get the lines, "I didn't look at her, but stared ahead at everything and nothing, not wanting to see her beauty just now" because obviously after your friend gets infected with an alien spider bite and you just witnessed the sawing off of his arm, you're going to get distracted by that totally bangable chick, right? I mean I know when I'm on the run for my damn life while the world is collapsing around me and my loved ones are dead, I am going to make keen notes of all the fly, available people around me instead of oh I don't know, notes on how to KILL THE GIANT SPIDERS TRYING TO KILL ME. Trollololol.
But who cares? Chloe got super fat and lumpy, hatched her spider baby, and is dead, so whatevs, right? *snort*
Oh and the sex scene with Katie later where Matt says, "Maybe this was my way of once again dominating the female species on behalf of all my fallen comrades. Whatever the reason, behind my eyes I could see only red and my body burned just to take her. This wasn't making love. This was pure, human, animal sex." LOL WTF. Ah, a book written by a woman that uses women as wombs for evil creatures and shows men as either uncontrollable horny dumbshits or insane killers of women (Nigel), is just awesome, right? Haaaa *lights self on fire*
But there were some good characters. George is the old, wise, father type and very likable. Chris is the crazy scientist type, and is kind of useless, but harmless. I think there were some other decent guys thrown in with the crazies that followed Nigel, but honestly there were just so many stock characters that I had trouble keeping up with them and who was who after awhile.
And I was distracted by Matt Edge being King Idiot. After he knocks up Katie and she starts showing the exact same signs Chloe did when she was pregnant with the spider baby (drastic mood change, wanting to be alone and sleeping a lot, the weird smell thing), he chalks it down to her just "being bitchy" and goes about his ways. I'm not sure how this idiot ended up banging three chicks in this novel, two of them being the last "normal" women we even encounter after the spiders start attacking, but wow, dude must have had moves that I missed or something.
I know the focus of this class is on the monsters, but holy hell, I couldn't even keep my attention on the translucent spider beasts because I was too busy eye-rolling at the over-the-top blatant gender stereotypes, Matt's complete puddle of a brain, and holy stock characters batman. I liked Rebecca a lot until she was reduced to nothing but a vagina for Matt to send his sperm up once again. And then he has to hold her and hide her precious eyes from the black spider crawling out of John's mouth because clearly after everything else she's seen she must be protected at all costs by this man to save her. Sigh.
I was waiting for them to tell us it was virgin blood the spiders were getting sprayed with by the army at the end. My theory was virgins couldn't house the spider babies and once Matt deflowered them, then they could, but that never really came into question in the text.
Not that much of anything was really explained though. The explanation for the spiders growing inside these people was genetically modified foods? Are you freaking kidding me? I would have taken a crashed spaceship of spider aliens over that complete crap answer. It was barely tossed in there along with some "science experiments gone wrong" and then we're focusing again on Matt trying to keep it in his pants, and the oh god have to save the baby cliche, again.
The only thing that really gave me satisfaction was Nigel's slow, agonizing death because the bastard deserved that. Everything else was just exhaustively bland. I did not get the answers I wanted about the spiders origins and why the "special" blood hurt them. I'm also convinced Matt carries some weird DNA and makes women have spider babies, so I'm basically waiting for the cycle of Chloe and Katie to continue with Rebecca, but I guess we're not meant to think that with that oh-so-hopeful ending.
So overall, not a book I would read again. My eyes hurt from rolling them so much. The spider monsters weren't that threatening to me, and most of it just left me disappointed. But hey, if you're into mutant spiders mixed with stock characters sprinkled in sexism, maybe this is the book for you.
I felt like the end was oddly chopped too. Almost seemed like she was told to cut a hundred pages so she just tried to find a good transition point to do so.
ReplyDeleteI am SO glad someone else was as disturbed about Edge's relationships. I didn't do a feminist reading on the book, but now that you bring it up, I am asking myself, why the hell not? You hit it right on the head, the book is glaring with "walking womb" references to women. I love that you mention Edge's internal monologue concerning Chloe, who he claimed to love so much that he instantly went for the next available woman (incidentally the only woman known to be alive at this point). Oh and she has to be hot, and skinny, because we all know how fat in women in equal to corruption and the incubation of the end of humanity.
I was rather light-hearted about the whole thing until I read your post. Good perspective, thanks for sharing!
Amen. Amen to all of this. I also wanted to have Matt drawn and quartered. The whole way through I was like what do these women see in him? If it were me and him left the human race would die out because I would have beat the shit out of him and tossed him to the spiders. I also thought that it might me virgin blood that killed the spiders and was equally upset when it never really said why the blood from the blind killed them. That doesn't even make sense. I also got beyond pissed when they failed to say why the creatures were there in a real or plausible fashion.
ReplyDeleteFor some reason it's hilarious that you used the word "deflowering" in a sentence about Matthew Edge. Ugh, what a dork.
ReplyDeleteAnyway, I agree with the scene involving John and the spider erupting from his face. I don't have much good to say about this book, but that was a cool/gross scene.
I also hate the whole "man taking care of a weak woman" trope. I saw it recently in a Brian Keene book and that, along with the horrible dialogue, was enough for me to stop reading. Mr Edge sheilding the helpless Rebecca's eyes made me gag. Whatever dude...
You started to delve into it, but I have really been wondering how a woman came about writing a book with such cliched, sexist characters. A book about pregnancy looking so horrific. Did she undergo some kind of similar experience with a douchebag like Mr Matthew Edge? Was she a "baby's mama" who was told she was fat and disgusting by the man who deposited his sperm into her? Just makes me wonder. If I'm write, I'd like to think she could take a bad experience like that and not relegate it to dime-store drivel like she did.
We had very similar opinions about Matt. I found the sex scene to be uncharacteristic of the same man who'd loved his wife. Granted, his love of his wife was a bit simple, but I figured they were young lovers. I also found his cognizance of his selfishness during sex to be unbelievable. Guys really don't analyze their feelings and thoughts during sex. I kept waiting for him to break out a calculator and graph paper and start making metrics to measure his feelings. I guess the first thing to go were the mechanical pencils, but that was edited out.
ReplyDeleteIt was unbelievable and it didn't work as feminist literature. It was like a feminist story written for a misogynistic market. It was really... weird.
Sara,
ReplyDeleteI totally agree with you. And with Mattandrewwriting. I didn't speak to it much in my post because I totally forgot, but it seemed really, really odd for a female author to have such a sexist and flat protagonist. But then again, maybe that's how she sees all men? I think the kind of exaggerated the man-ish/womanly aspects of both sexes at different points...but still it's not really something that's well done enough that I can claim that it's intentional. I think that was one of the biggest problems of this book: stuff that could have been cool but was so glazed over that it really just comes off as laziness and poor attention to detail.
The Nigel thing kind of pissed me off too. "Oh he was an asshole, so we'll leave him to die a slow, agonizing death and then justify it with some "new world order' crap. If it was Katie or Rebecca that got bit you know that Matt 'sexypants' Edge would have scoured the earth for a cure...or maybe not...maybe he'd just move on to jane, you know, once she wasn't a kid anymore.
Loved your post, btw, was super funny.
Great post, Sara! I wasn't quite so down on this book as you, I found some redeeming qualities for one, and I actually found the spiders pretty gruesome. I did notice many of the same issues as you did (I gave it a D+ over on my blog, so it's not like I liked it).
ReplyDeleteI am really curious about Sarah Pinborough's treatment of both genders in the book. The character Matthew Edge, was a pretty awful sexist sort of guy, but was he made that way for a reason? Why did the women seem so weak? Was she trying to say that is how men view women? Oddly, that feels sexist towards men. I'd like to give SP the benefit of the doubt that she was hoping to raise these sort of questions in her audience, but I suspect it was done more out of a sense of "this is so like a man, amiright, ladies?"
Haha I love you. This blog had me laughing so hard.
ReplyDeleteI actually didn't hate this book, mainly because I think I took a lot of it as humorous and imagined it as a 1950's horror flick the whole time.
I will definitely agree that the "I'm gonna have rough sex with this girl because fuck women" thing REALLY pissed me off.
You should try reading the sequel to this, it's pretty out there. And no it doesn't follow Matt, which made me feel even more let down by the ending. But not as much as the sorry excuses for science in this novel did.
Hahahaha... this is absolutely fantastic! Great post!
ReplyDeleteAt one point, I wondered if this was an attempt at a reverse stereotype. Matt was presented in such an over the top way that I thought... this can't be real. But by the end we're back to the same old big man save little woman tropes so I guessed we weren't in a comedy. But really, we're not that far from it either.
I think making Matt the cause of this by making his sperm the reason for the transformation would have been comic gold (fantastic idea)! Then we could see him struggle with his desires... "She's hot... but if we hookup she'll die... what would Jesus do?!" That's about the level of emotional conflict I'd expect from this book.